The Early Commuter
My Best Mathematical and Logic Puzzles
Solved October 13, 2026
Every day a commuter arrives at his suburban station at 5:00 and his wife, who leaves home so as to reach the station at exactly that time, drives him the rest of the way home. One day he catches an earlier train and reaches the station at 4:00. Rather than wait, he starts walking home along the route his wife drives. She leaves home at her usual time, meets him along the way, picks him up, and turns around. They reach home 10 minutes earlier than they normally would.
Assuming the wife always drives at the same constant speed and left home at her usual time, how long was the husband walking before she picked him up?
My solution
He must have walked for 55 minutes.
Note I am not totally satisfied with the following derivation, it just kind of “falls out” of the equations, and I think there must be a more geometric / visual way to see this. Anyways. Let the arrival time home on a normal day be and the arrival time today be
we have (the algebra throughout is in minutes)
Define the driving time in minutes, one way (from home to station or vice versa), on a normal day as . We are given .
Define the time in minutes spent today walking, then driving as and respectively. We are given .
Finally define the wife’s departure time as .
We have and . See that
Or in other words, the wife spends 5 minutes less driving each way than usual. Now see
and see that this implies
Or in other words, the amount of travel time from the station to home is 50 minutes longer today than it normally is
Finally, substitute in
from earlier. This is essentially saying “5 minutes less than the usual driving time plus some amount of walking equals the usual amount of driving plus 50 minutes” which is a trippy thing to think about. It easily follows that
So the amount of time walking must have been 55 minutes.
Interestingly, it doesn’t matter how far away the home is, that is, when the wife leaves or how long she drives. If then is preserved.