The Fork in the Road
My Best Mathematical and Logic Puzzles
Solved October 5, 2026
A traveler comes to a fork where one road leads to safety and the other to ruin, but he doesn’t know which is which. Two local men stand there. One of them always tells the truth and the other always lies, and the traveler has no way of telling them apart.
He is allowed to point at one road and ask one of the men a single yes-or-no question. What question can he ask that will reveal, from the answer alone, which road is the safe one?
My solution
I’ve heard this one before so I decided to answer in the form of a poem.
“Which way would the other say?” Is the question for that day
For if the liar you happen to ask Will be given an impossible task
Lie, he will, with all his might And say “go left” if the truth says right
But if you ask the one that’s true He will tell of the liar to you
And truthfully say that he would lie And lead you down the path to die
So no matter which you ask the question Follow the opposite of their suggestion!