Water and Wine
My Best Mathematical and Logic Puzzles
In the well-known puzzle, one beaker holds water and another holds wine. Some water is moved into the wine, then the same volume of the resulting mixture is moved back. Is there now more water in the wine than wine in the water? (They turn out to be equal.)
Raymond Smullyan asks a follow-up. Suppose one beaker starts with 10 ounces of water and the other with 10 ounces of wine. You repeatedly shuttle 3 ounces from one beaker to the other and back, stirring after each transfer, as many times as you like. Can you ever reach a state in which both beakers have the same percentage of wine?