Draw Poker
My Best Mathematical and Logic Puzzles
Solved October 2, 2026
Two players draw cards from a single ordinary 52-card deck to each build the best possible five-card poker hand. The deck is face up, so each player can see and deliberately choose which cards to take; they draw alternately, the first player going first, until each holds five cards.
The first player claims that with correct play he can always guarantee a win. Which five cards should he aim to collect, and why does that choice assure that the second player can never beat him?
My solution
They must pick all 4 “10” cards, then any other card for the 5th.
The best hand is a straight flush (SF). With all of the 10’s, the first player is the only one who could ever complete an AKQJ10 SF, (an A-high SF) or a K-high, Q-high, J-high, or 10-high SF.
The highest hand the second player can make now is a 9-high SF. Their only hope of winning is to “block” the first player from making a 10-high SF or better (on the 1st player’s 2nd draw), with their (the second player’s) first draw.
To do this, they need to take 1 card from each suit of rank A-J AND 9-6. That is 8 cards at minimum.
With only 5 cards to take, the second player will always leave an available SF for the first player to complete on their second draw, of value 10-high or better.
With 9-high SF remaining the second player’s best possible hand, the first player always wins with this strategy.